Editor’s note: The following story is written by Matt Alley, BlueCollarWriter Labor Media and was originally published on Patreon on January 9, 2026. Renee Nicole Good is the third person to be killed by ICE in the streets, after Silverio Villegas González from the Chicagoland area, and Keith Porter in Los Angeles. The Tribuno del Pueblo would like to remember their lives and the thousands of lives lost in detention centers.
On January 7, 2026, in broad daylight on a residential street in Minneapolis, Renee Nicole Good — a 37-year-old mother of three, poet, writer, U.S. citizen, and volunteer legal observer — was shot and killed by an ICE agent during a federal immigration operation.
Good wasn’t a target. She wasn’t a suspect. She wasn’t committing a crime. She was there to observe and document federal enforcement activity — a role rooted in civil rights history — meant to ensure accountability and protect the rights of others. She was leaving the scene when an ICE agent fired into her vehicle, striking her in the head and killing her.
That fact alone should stop the country cold.
Instead, we were immediately fed a carefully engineered narrative designed to excuse the killing and shift blame onto the victim.
The Lie Comes First
Within hours, Republicans and federal officials rushed to frame Renee Good as dangerous, reckless, even terroristic. We were told the agent feared for their life. We were told she used her vehicle as a weapon. We were told this was self-defense.
But video evidence and eyewitness accounts tell a different story — one that undermines the official version and exposes it for what it is: damage control for state violence.
This is a familiar playbook. When civilians are killed by the state, the truth becomes inconvenient. So it gets buried under talking points, insinuations, and character assassination. The victim is put on trial while the shooter is shielded by authority, uniform, and bureaucracy.
Calling a legal observer a “domestic terrorist” isn’t just dishonest — it’s dangerous. It sends a clear message: watching the government is now a punishable act.
This Is What Social Decay Looks Like
Renee Good’s killing is not an isolated incident. It is a symptom of a deeper rot.
We are witnessing the normalization of militarized federal force operating with minimal transparency and even less accountability. Masked agents. Aggressive tactics. Weapons drawn in civilian neighborhoods. All justified in the name of enforcement, order, or “security.”
When law enforcement stops seeing the public as citizens and starts viewing them as threats, the social contract collapses.
This is how rights die — not all at once, but through precedent and silence.
The right to observe.
The right to document.
The right to be present without being executed for it.
These are not fringe ideas. They are foundational.
Law Without Accountability Is Not Law
What makes this killing especially chilling is not just the act itself, but the response. Federal agencies immediately circled the wagons. State and local authorities were sidelined. The same institution that pulled the trigger controls the narrative, the evidence, and the investigation.
That is not justice. That is power protecting itself.
When the state kills a civilian and refuses meaningful oversight, the rule of law becomes a performance — something invoked when convenient and discarded when it isn’t.
A Warning, Not an Exception
Renee Nicole Good was a mother. A writer. A community member. A citizen exercising what should have been a protected role.
Her death is a warning shot to anyone who believes rights still function the way we were taught they do.
If legal observers can be killed and smeared. If federal agents can shoot first and spin later. If political leaders can lie in real time and face no consequences.
Then we are not talking about immigration policy anymore. We are talking about what kind of country we are becoming.
This isn’t about left or right. It’s about whether human life still matters when it stands in the way of power — and whether we are willing to tell the truth when the state wants silence.
Renee Good should be alive.
The fact that she isn’t should terrify anyone who still believes in rights, accountability, and the idea that the government answers to the people — not the other way around.
_______________________________________________________________________
El Tribuno del Pueblo brings you articles written by individuals and/or organizations, along with our reporting. Bylined articles reflect the views of the authors. Unsigned articles reflect the views of the editorial board. Please credit the source when sharing: tribunodelpueblo.org. We’re volunteers, but some of us receive a stipend. Please donate at http://tribunodelpueblo.org to keep bringing you the voices of the movement because no human being is illegal.
